Creating a Comparison Matrix
Charles Bailey has published a very helpful bibliography (Digital Curation and Preservation Bibliography, v.1), from which the resources below were gleaned. In addition, I have been adding resources to Mendeley, a research management tool: Digital Curation, Digital Library Best Practices & Guidelines, Digital Library Systems, and Metadata.
- Archival Management Software, A Report for the Council on Library and Information Resources, January, 2009
- Wiki updates to Archival Management Software report to CLIR (above)
- Choosing a System for Managing Your Image Collection (from JISC), 2007
- Collection Management and Creation Strategies for UC Special Collections and Archives, Summary and Features Matrix (pdf document, see also the Appendices, which are spreadsheets)
- Archives Management Software Review (from the Council of Nova Scotia Archives)
I have added a few more open source items, and a lot of proprietary systems I discovered thanks to Mr. Bailey’s rich resource. I am constructing a matrix of features for comparison, borrowing from the reports above and my initial chart, based mainly on features that are most important for our needs:
- Product
- URL
- Owned by/Maintained by
- License type
- Runs on (OS)
- Database
- Server Software
- Interoperability with Digital Repository Systems
- Works with (what other software)
- Programming Lang
- Additional hardware or software required
- Hosting available
- OAI-PMH?
- Rights management
- Manage Restricted Materials
- User submission
- Set processing priorities
- Manage processing status
- Localization options
- Formats supported
- Image file import (TIFF, JPEG, etc.)
- A/V file import
- Text file import (TEI, PDF, etc.)
- Image file management w/ associated metadata
- A/V file management w/ associated metadata
- Text file management w/ associated metadata
- Batch edit
- DC type
- METS
- MODS
- MARC
- Imports (MARC , EAD, Tab Delimited/CSV
- Batch Import (MARC, EAD, CSV)
- Exports (MARC, EAD, MADS, MODS, METS, Dublin Core, EAC, Tab Delimited)
- Batch Exports (MARC, EAD, MADS, MODS, METS, Dublin Core, EAC, Tab Delimited)
- Easy Data Entry
- Spell Check
- PREMIS?
- Other Schemas
- Create description record from existing record and automatically populate fields
- Item-level Description
- Link accession and description records
- Link accession record to multiple description records
- Link description record to multiple accession records
- Hierarchical – fonds, collection, sous-fonds, series, sub-series, files, items and link with its parts in the hierarchy.
- Ability to reorganize hierarchies
- Flexibility of Data Model
- Templating/default fields
- Controlled vocabularies
- Authority Records
- Link authority record to unlimited description records
- Link description record to unlimited authority records
- Compliance to Archival Standards
- Data validation
- Backup/Restore utility
- Integrated Web Publication
- Public search interface
- Advanced search (by field)
- Faceted Search
- Browse levels
- Search results clearly indicate hierarchical relationships of records
- Records linked to other parts of hierarchy
- User Access and Data Security Function
- Control who can delete records
- User permissions management
- Control when record becomes publicly accessible
- Feeds
- Install Notes
- Forum/List URL
- Bug tracker URL
- Feature Req URL
- Trial/demo/sandbox
- Training available
- Technical support provided by developers
- User Manuals (user, admin)
- Context-specific help
- Page turning
- Developer customization available
- User customization permitted
- What reports
- Customize reports
- Repository statistics
- Plugins
- UTF